Judicial Review and "Land Under Cultivation" (1 minute read)

November 26, 2014

Judicial Review and “Land Under Cultivation” (1 minute read)

New Nadina Judicial Review Kamloops

In June, I found myself in Court in Kamloops, arguing in response to a Judicial Review Petition involving a 2013 order of the Surface Rights Board.  Last week, the B.C. Supreme Court decided in favour of my client, New Nadina Explorations Limited.  

A key issue before the Court was whether the Surface Rights Board’s interpretation of s. 11(2) of the Mineral Tenure Act was correct.  In the decision under review, the SRB had found that “land under cultivation” connoted a present, active, state of cultivation for the purpose of raising a crop.  As a result, the SRB found that “land under cultivation” had a seasonal aspect – once the seasonal opportunity to harvest or pasture a crop had passed, the lands would no longer be under cultivation until new cultivation activities began in the following season.

The B.C. Supreme Court found that this interpretation was correct – it was consistent with established principles of statutory interpretation and the applicable jurisprudence.  The Court dismissed the Petition for Judicial Review, with costs payable to New Nadina.

Click here for the decision of the B.C. Supreme Court.

Click here for the decision of the Surface Rights Board.

Click here for New Nadina’s News Release.

By Salim Hirji Civil Litigation Court Decisions Share:

Welcome to the Hirji Law Corporation Blog – commentary and information about business disputes and the litigation process.

I will be blogging about dispute resolution, negotiation, recent court decisions, and the impact that disputes can have on your business.

This website provides information only, and is not intended to provide or give legal advice, nor is it an offer or invitation for a lawyer-client relationship. You should not rely on the information provided here without first obtaining legal advice from a lawyer in your jurisdiction who understands your situation and represents your interests.